Top of the Docs: Season 9

Within one single post, Roger proves that we don’t always agree!

season 9

Day of the Daleks

RP: 3 – The Daleks were imposed on the writer, and then there were only three props available.  You can do a good story with only three Daleks, but an invasion isn’t one of them.

ML: 9 – Drastic difference, but I love the setting, love the pre-Terminator idea of creating the very future you’ve traveled back to stop, love the look of a Gold Dalek, love the idea of eating cheese and drinking wine in some dark house.  Only loses the top score of 10 because the Doctor guns down an Ogron in cold blood.  (Was it necessary?  I’d say not!)

The Curse of Peladon

RP: 5 – A parable for the joining of the EEC, done in the most cynical manner, doubled up with a nasty approach to religion vs science.  But if you can ignore all that (or it goes over the top of your head), then it’s all a bit of bizarre fun.

ML: 8 – Bad hair and a horribly cliched approach to King Peladon falling for Jo loses this story at least a point.  But having the Ice Warriors appear and not be the villain is a triumph.

The Sea Devils

RP: 7 – The original Master’s finest hour, and the Sea Devils work much better as a fairly straightforward monster than the Silurians did as a clumsy attempt at a three-dimensional villain.

ML: 6 – Pretty average story; decent pacing, great use of the Master.  Hilarious listening to the Sea Devils scream when land mines detonate in front of them, but again it dragged a bit and had another Scooby Doo ending.  Damn that pesky Doctor!

The Mutants

RP: 3 – The writers did a brilliant job with this, but everyone took their great scripts and did horrible things with them.  All substance, no style.

ML: 2 – Not memorable at all.  Cool idea with the three cycled development of a species, but somehow nothing in this story sticks.

The Time Monster

RP: 5 – A lot of silly fun, with a story like something out of a Dr Who Annual.

ML: 2 – Great idea that goes nowhere.  Ignores that just a few seasons earlier we had an Atlantis story.  And drops to the point of idiocy the moment the Doctor builds that… thing!  “Here, let’s put a random assortment of kitchen utensils together with a bottle of wine and I can stop the Master’s time experiment!”  TEDIOUS!

Well, Rog and I have very different opinions of the first two of this season.  Again the pacing is stronger on the shorter episodes.  It’s harder to make the story interesting when there isn’t one.  Like pulling cotton apart, you can stretch it out, but when it gets so thin you can’t see it, does it matter?  ML

This entry was posted in Doctor Who, Entertainment, Random Chatter, Science Fiction, Top of the Docs. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Top of the Docs: Season 9

  1. scifimike70 says:

    The Day Of The Daleks: The Special Edition is the ultimate justice.

    The Curse Of Peladon: For the kind of story you’d expect to see in Star Trek, this shows how Dr. Who was really becoming more adaptable to other SF in the 70s.

    The Sea Devils: The sword-fight showdown between the Doctor and the Master is timeless.

    The Mutants: This is a quintessential example of how looking beyond the physically non-humanoid aspects of other beings has its moral benefits. Garrick Hagon who played Ky would later appear in the first Star Wars as Luke’s friend Biggs. So that makes it additionally memorable.

    The Time Monster: It was partly Pertwee’s first pseudo-historical adventure. So choosing Atlantis was imaginably ideal. Dave Prowse played the Minotaur and so the best connection between Dr. Who and Star Wars counts for an otherwise troubling story. From my point of view, it had a most morally educational ending where sparing the Master was concerned. Looking back now, even if the idea made the Master even more unforgettably villainous, making the Master responsible (for purely sci-fi/fantasy purposes) for the doom of Atlantis may earn mixed reviews today. But how it ended with finally seeing Kronos in a better light still works for me.

    The Doctor’s and Master’s TARDISes inside each other was pretty neat too.

    Thank you both for your reviews.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s