I love this episode. I don’t love it because of the great acting by Nimoy during his mind-meld, but because it really did something really amazing. It gave us the Horta. You’re probably thinking: why is that special? Look at the creatures that we’ve encountered up until now. The M-113 (salt vampire) is humanoid. The spores were plants; big orchids. The Talosians were humanoid. Balok, the Gorn, Khan, Landru… human(oid). Even the Squire of Gothos appears as human even if he is ultimately a flashlight spot on the universe. Not exactly awe-inspiring! The Horta, however, is the first alien in Trek that is truly alien. It doesn’t speak and only manages three etched-in-stone words: No Kill I after communing with Spock’s mind. (If you think about The Girl in the Fireplace from Doctor Who, a mind meld can be a two-way communing of minds, so Star Trek got to that idea first!) It’s a creature that, like any other, protects its young. But it is gloriously alien in all other respects. This opens an entire question which, considering this was 1967, is really interesting: can life exist that is not carbon based? According to Star Trek, it can but that may not be enough for reality. The idea of “no life as we know it” does open the mind to the possibility of other forms of life, totally alien to our way of understanding. For me, that’s “mind candy!”
Don’t misunderstand me; the episode is not flawless. The fact that the Horta decides to damage the planet’s power reactor is silly considering the creature probably didn’t attend Starfleet tech classes, yet it knew exactly what to take. And more importantly, considering its willingness to kill to protect its young, why only take the reactor when destroying it would have made more sense? I know Kirk looks over the shoulder of a redshirt when Spock is giving them their orders, but did he really memorize the cave map? And “a few thousand meters” was about 20 feet in the episode. Spock’s odds that he shares with Kirk about both of them dying is all well and good, even if exaggerated, but that does entail the idea that they don’t go exploring together; one big target. (I still want to comment on the base director’s poster that he pulls out of the maps… and then says nothing about it, only for Spock to tell Jim he’s “charted” the deaths. By looking at a maze?! But I’ll let that go…)
What I can’t let go is the positive outcome that will make the miners rich. I sure hope Jim arrested the people who brutally beat his security detail with clubs! Even if he understands their motivations, he better have dealt with that before giving them the keys to Aladdin’s cave.
That said, I still need to sing its praises. When a piece of the creature is blasted off, it still pulsates! I utterly love that little detail. I love that Spock is unwilling to commit genocide and even disobeys Jim’s orders to try to capture the creature… until Jim himself is in danger. Suddenly Spock changes his tune and he is ready to kill to save his friend. I love the Silicone nodules are actually eggs. And that they are large round orbs, not something Jon Pertwee can use to stir his coffee (See: Doctor Who: The Three Doctors). I love the little lesson about motherhood; that a mother will do anything to protect her young. It’s a simple, but effective message. And most of all, I love McCoy’s “I’m a doctor, not a bricklayer!” I wish I could use that somewhere.
I will tie this one up with yet one more Doctor Who knot. This story not only arrived at the two-way mind meld years before Doctor Who, it also introduced a creature called the Horta on the plant Janus. Interestingly, by January of 1977, exactly 10 years after this episode, Doctor Who gave us The Face of Evil. Significant only in that we find a small carnivore called the Horda. And Leela, introduced in this episode, uses the Janis thorn to paralyze people. Like Talos, Trek got there just a little ahead of Telos. Trek truly was a pioneer in science fiction. And this episode was, for my money, way ahead of its time! ML
The view from across the pond:
In this episode Kirk comes to the rescue of a mining operation that is being attacked by a monster. It’s a deadly monster too, capable of reducing men to a burning cinder in an instant, and tunnelling through rock and, well, just about anything. So we have a good, old-fashioned, Doctor Who base under siege, with a near-omnipotent and almost indestructible foe.
For the first third of the episode the monster is kept off-camera, and that is when it is at its most effective, an unseen enemy, picking off anyone foolish enough to go out alone into the mines (and apparently lots of the miners are foolish enough to do that). Once the nature of the threat is revealed it is a qualified success of a monster costume, rock-like, scuttling and inhuman in form, but a bit too fabric-like and silly to entirely convince. I suspect this is one that really scared the kids watching, but made more than a few adults laugh.
Once again, a Trek storyline relies on people doing foolish things. As soon as I saw that silver sphere I wrote in my notes “maybe it wants its ball back”. But the most foolish thing of all was the sight of Vanderberg, Kirk and Spock finding the door that says “Power Reactor” and “Caution Radiation” with a massive hole burnt into it, and just walking merrily through the hole. They’re going to feel that in the morning.
After far too many scenes of people wandering around tunnels and talking, we finally got to the point of the episode, and it’s another one that challenges assumptions. The thing with those Doctor Who base under siege stories, or just about any monster movie or television series you would care to name, is the plot is nearly always resolved by killing the monster. The hero might make an attempt at talking things through (and even that is rare), but a story about a monster attacking people is almost always going to end with the people finding a way to kill it. But this is Star Trek, and it makes us look at things in a new way.
First of all, Spock points out that the destruction of the creature would be genocide. He has a point, but so does Kirk when he points out how many people are dying. There is an uncomfortable theme running through these episodes though. Kirk never acknowledges who the invaders are. Once again, humans have landed on somebody else’s planet, started being attacked, and think that’s somebody else’s fault and they have a right to defend themselves, even to the point of genocide. This is the one area where Trek always comes across as a brave attempt at a morality tale but also as an attempt at a particular variety of storytelling that is in its infancy. The ethics are never quite thought through. But in common with many other episodes, Kirk’s mind is finally opened and he does the right thing when given a chance.
NO KILL I
The scuttling thing burning letters into the ground is unintentionally amusing, but by this point it doesn’t matter, because this is a story being delivered with such conviction. Just look at how well Leonard Nimoy sells the scenes of his mind meld with the creature. It could so easily have been his Creature from the Pit moment, but instead he commits fully and actually makes us care about this actor-shuffling-under-a-knobbly-rug.
And once again, Star Trek rejects the vicious circle of retribution and retaliation. The creature has killed many people, but Kirk has the compassion and intelligence to just stop for a moment and ask one vital question: why? How many conflicts could be resolved, on a personal and perhaps international level, by people just asking that simple question, trying to find out the motivations of their enemies? The miners’ “enemy” is nothing more than a mother protecting her eggs, which they have been merrily smashing to pieces. So there is understanding, healing, and finally a compromise is reached that benefits everyone. I am watching Star Trek for the first time, over 50 years since it was first broadcast, and yet it is one of the most enlightened and refreshing series I have ever seen. RP